The supreme at Pepperoni's is not bad and the Hawaiian is ok too. Prices and service are great.
Collina's on Richmond is still excellent (and still BYOB/W)
Dolce Vita is overpriced (thus they closed last month)
Romano's is average but the other dinner dishes are pretty good and include a huge salad and garlic bread
Star is average but at least has a buffet lunch (or did)
Stuffed pizza at Chicago Beef and Pizza is not really Chicago stuffed, just about ten pounds of cheese.
Double Dave's is average but lunch buffet is a bargain (if it reopens) and pepperoni rolls are unique
Pink's is kind of bad